06 September 2011

Marriage Payment: An Aspect Of Marriage Institution Practiced Among The Chikimis In Manipur

By Priyadarshni M. Gangte

wedding kuki chin mizoThe Chin-Kuki-Mizo is a grouping of people comprising of several ethnic groups who are closely allied to one another. For the purpose of this paper, Chin-Kuki-Mizo is clubbed together as the CHIKIM that literally means ‘all nationalities’. These ‘nationalities’ have a common culture, tradition, language, custom, mode of cultivation, form of government, etc. They inhabit entire Chin Hills of Myanmar and are known ‘Chin’ in that country. These same groups of people are known as ‘Kuki’ when they are in the Indian states of Manipur, Nagaland, Tripura, Assam, etc. and also Chittagong Hill Tracts of Bangladesh. Similarly, in recent times, these people inhabiting erstwhile Lushai Hills District of Assam preferred to abandon the term and called themselves as ‘Mizo’ which is recognised by the Government of India and granted the state of Mizoram as belonging to the Mizo people. The present study will discuss the marriage payment, an aspect of marriage institution, among the following Chin-Kuki-Mizo people: Lushais, Thadou/Kuki, Lakher, Zomi/Chin and Old Kukis.

Marriage Payment

Marriage is a form of social arrangement by which a couple is legitimized in their physical relationship and their child is given a legitimate position in the society which is often determined by parenthood in the social sense 1 . Marriage payment forms parts of the social institution of marriage. Making of payment of marriage by the bridegroom either in the form of kind or service to the bride’s kin is an essential part of establishment of legality 2 . Marriage payment was held officially in South Africa as per native custom with payment of Mithun in general. Some people believe that ‘bride-price’ is a completed word of marriage payment, alleged to have been coined by British administrators during the colonial British period in India3 . In our study, marriage payment will be consistently used to mean marriage price or bride-price.

The Chikimis do not think of marriage necessarily, as a union, based on romantic love although beauty as well as character and health are always sought in choice of a wife. Secondly, in Chikimi society, a marriage involves making of payment by the bridegroom or his kin to the father or close relative of the would-be bride in case the father had expired. Such system of understanding of the nature of marriage alliance was also prevalent in a great number of societies in ancient and modern times in all parts of the world. Among few Chikimi tribes, practice of marriage payment is prevalent and is known as ‘bride-price’, which is paid in cash, kind and ‘mithun’. Our study of the marriage payment system among the Chikimi tribes has revealed that it is a widespread social practice in the northeast India and had significant sociological dimensions.

The Lushai

Marriage payment or bride-price or marriage price is the most important factor in a Chikimi marriage. No marriage can be performed unless part of marriage-payment is made in advance by the bridegroom to the bride’s family. It was paid in terms of mithuns when barter system was practice of the time. A mithun used to cost rupees forty as fixed by the British India administration in 18th Century when currency system was first introduced in this part of the North East. Some clans had fixed the prices for their maids in the past4 . It varied from four to ten mithuns depending upon the antecedents, blood and beauty of the bride. Marriage-payment for a chief’s daughter was as many as ten mithuns or more5  for the Dulien (Lushai) speaking Chikimis. Minor concessions could be given during the time of payment. In this connection, marriage payments were practically never paid up in full at once at the time of wedding for the reason that hardly anybody had enough money to pay the same at once 6 . Generally there was the custom of marriage-payment only in instalments and the remaining to be paid after some time i.e. twenty years or more7 . The customary laws of Thadou, Gangte, Vaiphei, Paite, etc. in this regard are quite widely different from the ones described hereinabove8

Marriage-payment is a sacred institution prevalent in Chikimi society. It is however not to be understood as a sale-price9 . It is not a commercial transaction.  Marriage payment was sometimes used as a weapon for a clever parent to reject a suitor10 If it is really felt that the usual payment of any part of the same was unduly delayed or was not intentionally paid, the aggrieved party could seek the chief’s permission to seize any of the property of the debtor against the claim11 .

The marriage payment consisted of two parts 12  (i) the Manpui and the Mantang. The Manpui is the price that has to go direct to the girl’s father or in his absence, to her brother. If she has none of them, it has to be received by her nearest male relative. The general rate of Manpui is five mithuns or Rs.100/- if the girl had dowry or ‘Thuam’ in the Dulien language but in case she does not carry, the rate of it was four mithuns each Mithun being fixed at Rs. 80/- by the British administrators. The custom of increasing Rs. 20/- was prevalent if the girl was provided with Thuam.

It is pertinent to mention that the Lushai (Dulien speaking Mizos) custom is slightly different from others in dealing with matters relating to marriage payment. It happened in circumstances where the girl was adopted by a man since childhood then the price went to him. In cases where male relatives failed to receive the marriage payment, the mother of the bride did not marry again and had taken all the responsibilities for her daughter (bride) she would let her mother receive the payment or she could select anyone to receive her marriage payment. In case her mother remarried and had gone to live with her husband under whose care the girl was brought up could be entitled to receive the marriage payment13 . In case she is a ‘Falak’ or illegitimate child, her mother could receive the marriage payment 14 .

During the course of our survey, we found that Parry was right about the ‘Mantang’ or the subsidiary price of the bride, which was normally distributed to different categories of persons15 .
(a) Sumhmahruai, Rs. 20/-, this price is payable to the bride’s father or brother.
(b) Sumfang, Rs. 8/- is payable to the bride’s father or brother.
(c) Pusum, Rs. 6/- goes to the bride’s ‘Pu’ (the maternal uncle of the bride).
(d) Palal, Rs. 5/- is to be received by any person, selected by the bride as adopted father. The Palal in reciprocal has to give the bride a fowl and Zubel (pot with rice beer) as Lawichal (wedding feast given by recipients of Mantang).
(e) Ni-ar, Rs. 2/- has to be received by the parental aunt.
(f) Naupuakpuan, Rs. 2/- is entitled by the bride’s elder sister in consideration of her having carried the bride about in her cloth when the child was a baby.

The above-mentioned subsidiary price or ‘Mantang’ are the integral parts of marriage payment. In addition to this, there are also two optional ‘mans’- they are Thianwan and Lawichal16 .
(i) Thianwan Rs. 2/- or Rs. 3/- is payable to a friend of the bride, it is from the Manpui. Thianman is refunded in case the bride left her husband sumchchuah (divorce of husband by wife) or Uire (adultery).
(ii) Lawichal Rs. 2/- is a payment (not compulsory) payable only when the bride and the bridegroom are from different villages. When the bride is escorted by a group of friends and a man, who leads them to the bridegroom’s residence. This man is known as ‘Lawichal’ in the language of Dulien speakers. He is sometimes rewarded Rs. 2/- which is also to be refunded in case the bride later leaves her husband ‘Sumchchuah’ or ‘Uire’.

Moreover, the following rates of marriage payment are realized:
(i) Tlai means head of one mithun’s price Rs. 20/-.
(ii) ‘Tlai Sial’ means half mithun Rs. 20/-.
(iii) ‘Sepui’ means a full grown mithun Rs. 40/-.
(iv) ‘Seding’ means a full grown mithun or Rs. 40/-.
(v) ‘Senufa’ means a mithun and calf or Rs. 60/-.
(vi) ‘Puikhat’ means Rs. 20/-.
(vii) ‘Puisawnsial’ means Rs. 20/-.

The Lakher

Marriage payment among the Lakhers was quite high and this worked as a deterrent to easy divorce and fortified the position of the wife. Like the Lushais, marriage payment in the Lakher-customs was shared by a long line of relatives even aunts of the bride have to receive part of it. Sometimes, sharing of the same was so complicated that litigations continued endlessly17 . The main price was called ‘angkia’. Higher clan Lakhers also adopted the custom of taking higher rate of ‘angkia’, which varied from 10 to 70 rupees. The different parts of the marriage payment, are the ‘angkia’, the ‘puma’, the ‘nongcheu’, the ‘nangcheu’, etc. All these prices have their own subsidiary prices18 .

The ‘angkia’(‘Angkia’ means house enter) as the main price is taken by the father of the bride. In some Lakher society, the ‘angkia’ is received by the eldest son (brother) for the eldest daughter. Likewise the youngest daughter’s angkia goes to the youngest brother.

The next payment is the ‘Puma’(‘Puma’ has the same significance of that other prices.) which is payable only to the bride ‘pupa’ who is her maternal uncle. The rate at which ‘puma’ is payable depends on the rate of the angkia and if it is 60 rupees the rate of the ‘pumapi’ or ‘puma’ payment is also 60 rupees and is generally claimed when the couple settles down as man and wife.

The third marriage payment is the ‘Nongchue’.( ‘Nongcheu’ is found to have exist only in the Lakher society.) which means ‘the mother’s price’. If the mother and father of the bride have been divorced, it is payable to the bride’s mother. If they are still married, it is payable to the bride’s mother’s sister.

The fourth marriage payment is the ‘Nangchue’‘Nangcheu’ is equivalent to Niman or Niar, and it is sometimes replaced by ‘Tini’), which means the aunt’s price and is payable to the bride’s eldest paternal aunt.

The Thadou / Kuki:

Among the Thadous, the marriage payment has an interesting legend19 . Chongthu was the younger brother of Nongmangpa, the Chief of the underworld. As per Thadou custom, in the presence of the elder brother called ‘Upa’, the younger brother called ‘Naopa’ cannot become a chief. So, Noimangpa, being the elder, was the chief, Chongthu also intended to become the Chief. Therefore, he went out in search of a suitable land where he could establish himself separately as a Chief. He found one. On his plan to become a chief, he wanted to go with his own closed friends whom he could trust. Thus, he arranged for the marriage of each of his selected men. In doing so he made the marriage payments of each bride to their parents. In those days, no valuable property or cash was available. All the valuable items that one could think of was a ‘Paigen’. This was a belt made of leather and decorated with a kind of beads, called ‘Longchang’, in seven lines. This was then considered to be a very rare and valuable item of property.
This could only be afforded by the chief alone. So, traditionally it became associated with the sole property, the right of which was vested only in the chief and was venerated very much being associated with a certain amount of superstition20 .

Chongthu being the younger brother of Noimangpa, the chief, had access to it and when he arranged for the brides of his friends with whom he planned to go to his newly found land, he paid the ‘Paigen’ to the parents of the girls as marriage payment. It so happened that though the commoners dared not refuse to accept the ‘Paigen’ when offered to them as marriage payment subsequently, they could neither dare keep it with them owing to their superstitions attached to it nor could they dare refuse the bride in marriage. 21 Thus,  along with the bride,  the parents returned the ‘Paigen’ to Chongthu saying that being a valuable property associated with the Chief exclusively, they dare not keep it or else, the wrath of the unseen supernatural power visit them and bring misfortune to them22 . This process went on and on until Chongthu was able to arrange 30 of his best and closest friends with the payment of ‘Paigen’ as the marriage payment.

Hereafter, marriage payment of every clan was paid in terms of seven mithuns based on the seven lines of ‘Longchung’ on the ‘Paigen’. This however needs further investigation and confirmation, the prevailing different versions on the matter among the Thadou tribes needs specific enquiries. Our research into ethnicity and folk lores reveal that since then marriage payment came to exist though in actual practice there are variations among the clans in terms of kind and number of mithuns. However, assuming that the following structure is the broad base for marriage payment as propounded by Crawford.

Bride-Price Structure of Thadous:
Clan Price
1. Doungel i) selsom (10 mithuns)
ii) dahpi ni (2 big copper gongs)
iii) dahbu ni (2 sets of three different small sizes of copper gongs)
iv) Khichang ni (2 ear beads)
v) Khichong ni (2 bead necklaces)

2. Sitlhou

3. Singson i) Selsomlanga (15 mithuns)

4. Kipgen i) selsom (10 mithuns)
ii) dahpi ni (2 big copper gongs)
iii) Khichong ni (2 bead necklaces)
iv) Khichang ni (2  ear beads )

5. Haokip

6. Chongloi i) Selsagee (7 mithuns)
ii) dahpi khat (1 big copper gong)
iii) dahbu khat (1 set of three different small sizes of copper gongs)
iv) Khichang khat (1 ear bead)
v) Khichong khat (1 bead necklace)

7. Hangshing

Though Crawford’s work is not comprehensive it serves an useful study on Thadou customary law for further exploration on the customary laws of the Thadous25 . Shaw,26   in his study on the Thadous, observed several deviations from what Crawford had specified in his work. He contended that the question of amount of marriage payment among the Thadous was not definite and commented that the chiefs and wealthy persons usually claimed and paid the equivalent of ten mithuns, Rs. 200/- in cash, 23 dahpi (large gongs), 2 dahpu (set of two gongs), 2 khichang (ear beads), 2 khichong (necklaces). He did not name any specific clan of the Thadous. He further opined that ordinary person often actually pay a couple of mithun, khichang and khichong. As in an instance, he said that a pig in some cases may be taken as one mithun and that as per his personal experience he had come across cases where Rs. 40 had stood for 4 mithuns, a jar of ‘ju’ for a khichang or khichong. Thus in actual practice the parent of the bride hardly ever received the marriage-payment in full but in the form of more or less fictitious substitutes. He was emphatic in this regard to the effect that the parents loved to name large amounts as the ‘man’ not with any idea of getting it, but to be able to boast that their daughter was married for so much. Often when enquired as to what precisely they had received, it was found that actually a much smaller amount had been accepted in full satisfaction by a system of fictitious values. This is very similar to the practices among the Lushais, Zomis, etc. Fictitious values have more often created false pretensions of wealth and richness, which became bones of contentions later and led to unhappy marriages.

It must also be mentioned that Hutton27  was convinced to have observed the fact that the first and last number of the marriage payment by mithun must necessarily be paid in mithun (selkeng-liding by this it means that marriage payment has to be by live-mithun). The first and the last marriage payment must in no case be substituted in any form of cash or kind.

Gangte28  another authority working on the marriage payment of the Thadous maintains that the marriage payment of the Singson Thadou is 30 mithuns without any other items added to it unlike the other Thadou clans. The higher rate of marriage payment among the Singsons has no origin according to him. It is said, the Singsons are the direct junior collaterals of the Sitlhous. So when their senior collateral (Sitlhous) increased the marriage payment the junior also deemed it proper to follow suit.29

During the course of our research we found that one common conspicuous missing fact is that of ‘Lutom Laisui’, a very important and compulsory item in the marriage payment. It signifies the importance of father and mother of the bride. ‘Lutom’ is given to the father of the bride in token expression of gratitude. Likewise, ‘Laisui’ is an exclusive item to be given to the mother of the bride for having given birth to her daughter from her naval. Here, it must be said that, while the father is shown respect for his paternal masculinity, the mother too is highly respected for giving birth to the child. In this regard, it is interesting to state that there cropped up differences between William Shaw and J.H. Hutton, who out of confusion literally dealt with the two terms out of ignorance of the language and meaning provided to the two items. Shaw30   attributed ‘Lutom’ as a gift given to the mother and ‘Laisui’ to the father. Hutton31  contended otherwise and explained that Shaw got it the wrong way round. In doing so, he explained saying that Laisui means a woman’s waist-band, while Lutom is a man’s loincloth. They were cloths for bride’s parent and further contended that it could be accounted for a money payment of Re. 1/- and Rs. 2/- respectively, that a woman can claim for property and that a Thadou woman can make in her own account.

Similarly, we found another feature that has not been dealt with by the several authorities in regard to Manpi which stands for principal marriage-payment that consists of one mithun on the tail of which one piece of big bead ‘khichang’ through the ear of which the tail of the mithun can be made to pass through as a decorative piece (Ibid). This bead is counted as equivalent to one mithun. Therefore, the Manpi or the principal mithun is counted as to bear the price of two mithuns. The principal mithun is expected to have given birth to as many calves as possible. It is believed that with such principal mithun included in the marriage payment similar number of many children are in return given birth by the bride. Therefore it is insisted that such principal mithun should necessarily reveal calf bearing32 .

We also observed that the broad based marriage payment as shown above is not totally followed by different clans. As for an instance, the Haokips of Chassad lineage known as the seniormost (piba) of the Haokip take ten mithuns inclusive of the principal mithun33  However, as for other junior lineages of the Haokip clan of the Thadou, the marriage payment is fixed at eight mithuns.

Another pertinent point we have observed i.e. the fact that though the marriage-payments of different clans are fixed it is customarily not paid in full throughout the life time of the bride. The practice of marriage payment is that provided the principal mithun accompanied by one or more subsidiary mithun can be paid, the remaining marriage payment be not necessarily in terms of mithuns. They can be substituted in kind. Symbolically the counting could represent mithun depending on the agreement between the groom’s and bride’s parties34 .

The Zomi/Chin

Among the Zomis the payment of marriage price also forms an integral part which has a high social value. In their custom, it is also called ‘Manpi’ (principal price). In every society of Zomi (chin) or Kuki or Chikimi tribes, unlike the Meitei’s, marriage ceremony process takes two days, one for sending off the bride by the parents, and another day for wedding, which is to be performed at the bridegroom’s place. A would-be bride cannot be send-off unless and until the question of ‘Manpi’ is settled as mentioned earlier. This is paid by the bridegroom side to the bride’s parents and has to be received by the father of the bride. In case he is dead, the price goes to the nearest male relative on his side, preferably, to the eldest or the youngest male member who is the heir-apparent.

In general, among the average Zomi, marriage payment ‘Manpi’ or principal price is fixed normally on the following four factors35
(i) the clan to which the bride belongs,
(ii) the amount of dowry the bride carries,
(iii)  the beauty of her
(iv) mutual understanding.

If the bride belongs to chief’s clan or aristocratic family, the normal price of such bride is ten mithuns or equivalent value of ten mithuns in terms of rupees but only in name. Once the principal marriage payment i.e. one life-mithun is paid, the rest of the price can be substituted in kind like gong, even valuable household utensils made of copper, silver, alluminium, etc.36  When marriage is solemnized the parents of the bride offer a sumptuous feast in bidding fare-well to their daughter by sacrificing a pig or a cow or two pigs or two cows depending on their capacity and quantum of guests. This is a normal standard followed by an average Zomi. In symbolic significance of final settlement of marriage negotiation all the elders from both the sides gather with a mug of rice bear each in their hands would partake specific portions of the sacrificial meat together. This is known as ‘witness supper’ of the marriage. This ‘witness supper’ is preceded with formal handing over of the marriage payment. After deliberation they have to agree finally by accepting the marriage payment or totally refunding the same in good faith, which occur rarely.

The following is the generally accepted agreement by Zo or Zomi or ‘Chin’ as far as the marriage-payment is concerned.. It is practiced even today.
Sialsuam (ten mithuns) - Chief or Aristocratic clan.
Sialthum (three Mithuns) - Commoners.

Though virtually covered under the Zomi Customary Law as described hereinabove, marriage payment of the Paites is a bit different. The marriage-payment among them is normally one mithun and a calf, ‘Sial Nuta’. As per fixation of the British administration, one full grown Mithun costs Rs. 40/- and Rs. 20/- for a Mithun calf called ‘Tai’ or ‘Tlai’ which means half. Zomi clans like Zou takes only ‘Sialnga’ (five mithuns) only. The Zous stick to maintaining their customs since time immemorial. The obligation of the bridegroom towards the bride’s party is significant in their social and cultural life. Any relationship between two clans who are involved can also play a role in determining marriage. Thus we find that sometimes the marriage payment can only be symbolic which means the expenses of the wedding ceremony are counted as marriage payment. If a poor boy is not in a position to pay he may be allowed to pay later. A boy may also be exempted from paying the same if he causes elopement of the girl and also if he simply moves to the house of the girl and waits until the girl is ready to marry him37 .

In addition to ‘Manpi’, there are also the other subsidiary marriage-payments. They are as follows:
(i) Puchum Rs. 4/- goes to the maternal uncle of the bride.
(ii) Niman is equal to that of Pusum, which is to be accepted by the paternal aunt.
(iii) Thaman or Palal equal to that of Pusum is the labour or service price to be reciprocated for taking the charge of the parents of the bride and is usually given for the head of the family. It is prevalent among the Gangte, the Paite, the Simte, the Thadou, the Vaiphei also.
(iv) Thallouh ‘sum’ (price goes also to the nearest relative of the head of the family.
(v) Lamman or Thiansum is a small amount of money that goes to a bride’s friend as a token of love.
(vi) Nuapuan puak ‘man’ is the price for the cloth used for carrying the bride when she was a child by her mother or elder sister. It varies from Rs. 4/- to Rs. 20/- as the class of the clan she belongs to. These payments in cash or kind suggest complete cessation of ties of the girl who is getting married with her family as she has to start her own family with full devotion and understanding.

Thakur38  contended that a wealthy commoner can often pay a high marriage price and so marries a woman of high class, and if his descendants continue this practice they will achieve high status rank with many privileges of the aristocratic class, except, of course, the same in the line of possible succession to hereditary headmanship or chieftainship.

The Old Kukis

Among the Aimol, Anal, Chiru, Chothe, Kolhen, Kom and Purum, the marriage payment is also divided into several parts. To mention a few of them is that, among the Aimol, the bride’s eldest brother gets Rs. 6/- and each of the other one rupee less than his immediate senior. The paternal and maternal uncles receive Rs. 2/- each, the aunt and the elder sister also receive Rs. 1/- each as niman.  Among the Anal and Purum the marriage payment must not be less than a pig and a piece of iron a cubit in length but the girl’s relatives try to get as much as they can. The bridegroom has also to feast the family of his bride three times on pork, fowls and rice washed down of course with plenty of Zu. But a Chiru girl has a marriage payment of only one gong. A Chothe girl’s marriage payment comprises of a spear, a dao and a fowl and the same is sealed by the consumption of much Zu. The marriage payment of a Kolhen girl is a gong and Rs. 7/- to her mother and Rs. 7/- each to the elder and younger brother and the maternal uncle.

The marriage payment of the Kom girl is very high, the father receiving one gong, four buffaloes, fifteen cloths, a hoe, and a spear, the aunt taking a black and white cloth. The Lamgang bridegroom has to pay his father-in-law three pigs or buffaloes or cows, one sting of conch-shell beads, one lead bracelet and one black or blue petticoat. A Tikhup father of the bride receives a gong, ten hoes, one dao and one spear and also Rs. 7/- by maternal grandfather. Apart from paying all items of marriage payments such as mithun, cow, pig, gong, bead, necklace, spears, dao, money and whatever ought to be paid by the bridegroom, three years service is to be served to the bride’s family. This practice is prevalent among the Aimol, Anal, Chiru and Purum. During this period of service he works with dedication as if he were a son of the house.39

Our survey has shown that the low rates mentioned as marriage-payments are certainly due to the sluggish economic wealth generation and poor economic condition of the tribes. Even today the plight of the many tribes is not better off. These monetary gifts became rational but the responsibilities that the marriage entailed for both the bride and the bridegroom was enormous. Responsibilities were indeed domineering over both the parties. The spirit of sharing responsibilities was reflected in the methods of gift exchange and their acceptance.

In conclusion, we want to say that in none of the Chin-Kuki-Mizo tribes (Chikimis) not a trace of customary law relating to women succession and inheritance was found to have been mentioned whatsoever 40 . To bring a change in the mindset of masses, certainly, education is the only weapon by which social trend is made to a twist steadily or suddenly. In this regard we cannot solely depend on women only; here male participation is considerably essential. Despite the winds of change brought about by modernism, Christianity and innovations of all sorts of comforts and development in life by science and technology traditionalism still stands firm in the dynamics of system of marriage. Marriage payment is, of course, the pivotal part in a Chikimis marriage, however, with the advent of globalisation, so also with a democratic set up norms have somehow impacted these ethnic groups. The traditional systems never recognised the rights of women as primary decision-makers in matters of community issue take inter-ethnic conflict crises management, social sanctions, etc. Their customary laws prevalent among these ethnic groups, though portray an egalitarian socio-economic structure is discriminatory when it comes to women’s right in traditional governance and customary laws.

Bangladesh-India Symbiosis

By Syed Yamin Bakht

India Bangladesh northeast IndiaBangladesh and India should move towards building a long-term symbiotic relationship in which both the countries can benefit from each other's proximity.

India is the closest geographical neighbor of Bangladesh. The two countries share a 4096-km long land border and it is the longest border that India has with any of its neighbors. More importantly, the land border almost surrounds Bangladesh while it nearly detaches the "Seven Sister" states of northeast India from the rest of that country. These are geographical facts which nobody can deny and we all must accept. In addition, both the countries have deep historic cultural and social ties. And none can forget India's unflinching support during our glorious War of Liberation.

Thus, it is essential that the bilateral relations between the two countries should be developed in such a way that the national priorities and needs of each are met and it is beneficial to both the countries. The bilateral ties have been showing signs of improvement in recent years and it is likely to be further consolidated with the visit of the Indian prime minister to Bangladesh.

India is keen on getting the transit facility and ensuring security cooperation to stop any future cross-boarder terrorist activities. What are the priorities for Bangladesh? It is yet to be spelt out publicly other than to publicize the fact that we will be economically benefited by providing the transit facility to India and by extension to Nepal and Bhutan.

However, to develop the bilateral relationship with India, we also need to identify and clearly spell out our own priorities. Only after formulating a credible and acceptable negotiating strategy we can move towards the bargaining table so that mutually beneficial ties can be established.

As far as Bangladesh's bargaining chips vis-à-vis India is concerned, transit is perhaps our biggest trump card and we should use it to resolve the major outstanding bilateral issues with the country. Except for the "chicken neck" corridor on the north of the Paschimbanga state, the seven northeastern states are virtually cut off from the rest of India by the geographic entity of Bangladesh. Thus, development and economic progress in this region has been lagging far behind the rest of India. And this, in turn, has led the people in the region to become disgruntled, even raising the ugly face of militancy. Hence, the importance of the transit facility for India cannot be underestimated.

A framework agreement which will include the much-talked about transit issue is slated to be signed between the two countries during the visit of the Indian prime minister. But what are we getting in return? While progress towards resolving some bilateral issues is perhaps being made, some other major issues seem to remain unattended.

It is good that some progress is being made towards resolving the long outstanding border demarcation and enclave issues. A joint survey has already been conducted. This is long overdue. As per the Mujib-Indira agreement of 1974, we gave up the Berubari enclave but India failed to live up to her end of the bargain. Our fellow citizens living in the Tinbigha enclave are virtually detached from the country till today, although a corridor was given with many restrictions.

However, no progress has yet been made on demarcating the maritime boundary along with the issue of the South Talpatty islands. This is an extremely important issue and must be dealt with and resolved.

A possible agreement on sharing of the Teesta and Feni river waters is another bit of progress. But it must be ensured that there is a 'guarantee clause' included in any such agreement, so that the minimum quantity of water that we are to receive is clearly spelt out. The 'guarantee clause' was not included in the Ganges water treaty signed in 1996. The same mistake must not be repeated again.

And what about sharing the waters of the other common rivers? A total of 54 rivers flow through India and into Bangladesh. What is our negotiating strategy on this issue? The most glaring omission from the negotiating table so far is the issue of Tipaimukh dam that India is building in the Barak valley. According to experts, this dam will reduce the water flow in the Surma and Kushiara rivers and will have an adverse impact on the Sylhet region as a whole.

India must respect the rights of the lower-riparian country as per international laws. It should not take any steps to alter the natural flow of any of the common rivers which can be detrimental to Bangladesh.

The ever growing bilateral trade imbalance in favor of India also must be adequately addressed. Bangladesh is an important trading partner for India as 15 per cent of the country's imports originate from that country. The two-way trade during the 2010-11 fiscal year stood at US$ 5.1 billion with Bangladesh's imports from India amounting to $4.59 billion and exports totaling a mere $512 million.

Thus, India must take concrete steps to reduce the yawning bilateral trade gap. Tariff and non-tariff barriers must be removed to make it easier for Bangladeshi manufacturers to compete in the large and growing Indian domestic market.

Another outstanding major issue which needs to be resolved with India is the indiscriminate border killings of civilians. Despite earlier assurances from the Indian government, this atrocity still continues in violation of all international norms and conventions. This has to stop immediately.

These and all other outstanding bilateral issues between the two countries should be resolved under an agreed framework and within a given timeframe. All issues can be amicably resolved, provided there is an atmosphere of trust and goodwill between the two countries. Building trust is a long-term process. And to do that, India should change its "big-brotherly" attitude towards its smaller neighbors. This, in turn, will help reduce the India "phobia" that exists in Bangladesh.

Any relationship is based on give-and-take and the Bangladesh-India ties should also follow along the same lines without sacrificing the national interests of either country. On the whole, the bilateral relationship must be based on mutual respect, good neighborly attitude and on an even keel. And it must produce a win-win situation for both sides.

**Syed Yamin Bakht can be contacted at yaminbakht58@gmail.com

05 September 2011

Kashmir, Manipur, And The Art Of Yawning

india yawningModerate Hurriyat Conference chairman Mirwaiz Umar Farooq appealed to Anna Hazare to launch a campaign for seeking answers from the government regarding unmarked graves in Kashmir

By Sandipan Deb

In his Eid sermon at Srinagar’s Eidgah prayer ground, moderate Hurriyat Conference chairman Mirwaiz Umar Farooq appealed to Anna Hazare and his team to launch a campaign for seeking answers from the government regarding unmarked graves in Kashmir. He said later that he planned to send a formal letter to Hazare and seek his help.

Three days before this, The Hindu reported Irom Sharmila, the iconic civil rights activist from Manipur, inviting Anna to visit her state, calling it “the most corruption-affected region in the world”. Sharmila has been on a hunger strike for nearly 11 years now, demanding the repeal of the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act which she blames for violence in Manipur and the Northeast. However, a few days later, she termed Hazare’s campaign against corruption as “somewhat artificial”, and said: “His struggle has been for a very, very short span but all the bureaucrats support it. I know those, those very prominent persons are corrupted.”

It’ll be interesting to see how Anna Hazare and his advisors react. Their movement touched a national chord because it attacked something -- corruption -- hat affects the lives of every common Indian. It tapped, with uncanny efficiency, the simmering hatred the average citizen feels about politicians, and was fueled by an extraordinary frenzy in the electronic media, which found in Anna just what the doctor ordered to boost TRPs.

But mass graves in Kashmir, with more than 2,000 unidentified bodies in them? For most Indians, I think, Kashmir is just a sort of droning noise in the background, that refuses to go away. And Manipur—how many of us can even name its capital? But this border state is where the Indian State has failed horrendously and totally: Manipur is a basket case, blighted by extreme corruption; zero development; non-existent infrastructure; multiple insurgency groups which, when not fighting government forces, fight one another or loot the citizens; massive drug and arms trafficking; unabated illegal immigration; human rights violations.

But neither we, nor our electronic media, with which we have formed a wonderfully symbiotic relationship, are concerned about tragedies that last too long. We yawn too easily.

Meanwhile, the BJP is planning two rath yatras in Uttar Pradesh next month. UP BJP spokesperson Vijay Bahadur Pathak told the Delhi newspaper Mail Today that the aim was to “maintain the impetus of Anna’s movement against corruption”. So what if on 26 August, at the Ramlila ground, Kiran Bedi, while doing her clown act on stage about Indian politicians, suddenly spotted BJP leaders Gopinath Munde and Ananth Kumar on the premises, insulted them and exhorted the crowd to force them to leave with shouts of “Chor chor…”

I suppose we’ll be seeing a bit more of the rath yatras on TV than Kashmir’s unmarked graves or Irom Sharmila’s unending odyssey.

YMA Opposes Granting OBC To Gorkhas

cymaAizawl, Sep 5 : The Mizoram government’s nod to grant OBC status to the Gorkhas in the state has drawn stiff opposition from three organisations, including the state’s most powerful organization Central Young Mizo Association (CYMA).

An executive committee meeting of the CYMA on September 2 strongly objected to the recent decision of the permanent body, set up in accordance with the directions of the Supreme Court, to give OBC status to the Gorkhas in Mizoram.

In the interest of social security of the Mizos, the CYMA is totally against granting OBC status to the Gorkhas in Mizoram, a source in the CYMA said.

The sources said both the previous ministries of the Congress and the Mizo National Front had looked into the Gorkhas demand for OBC status, but did not find it viable to fulfill the demand.

It is really unfortunate that the Permanent Body, chaired by Law Commission chairman and MLA Lalrinawma has agreed to give OBC status to the Gorkhas, it said.

If the Gorkhas were granted OBC status, 27 per cent of jobs would have to be reserved for them.

While the Gorkhas can apply for any job without reservation and many of them have got jobs in the state government, there is no need for them to get OBC status, the source said.

Two major students bodies had also expressed strong dislike to the decision.

The Mizo Students Union yesterday voiced their opposition against granting OBC status to the Gorkhas in Mizoram.

The Mizoram Government seems to be in favor of giving OBC status to the Gorkhas in Mizoram, the MSU leaders told the home minister.

It is very insensible to include Gorkhas in the OBC category as that would enable them to enjoy more privileges than the Mizos, who are under Schedule Tribe, as per the All India Reservation Policy, the MSU observed.

Granting OBC status to the Gorkhas could also lead to a demographic invasion by the Gorkhas living in other states of India, the MSU expressed fears.

The Mizo Zirlai Pawl (MZP), the state’s apex students body, in a recent statement, strongly condemned the Permanent Body s decision to give OBC status to the Gorkhas.

MZP would fight to the end to ensure that this decision did not materialize, the students body said in statement.

Saying that the decision to give OBC status to Gorkhas could be detrimental to the social security of the Mizos, the MZP appealed to all NGOs and political parties to be up in arms against it.

The MZP planned to convene a meeting of all parties and NGOs soon to discuss the issue.

The Young Mizo Association is also very likely to oppose the same. Mr Lalrinawma said the government wanted to ensure protection of the rights and privileges of the minorities under the provisions of the Constitution. The Gorkhas had been making appeals for inclusion in the OBC list for those who were staying in Mizoram on or before January 26, 1950 and their descendants.

The decision was made after conducting thorough study on how many of the Gorkhas were enrolled in the voters lists, how were they accorded the OBC status in eight states where the Gorkhas lived and reservations given for government jobs.

Rift Over Trade Licenses To Non-Mizos

nobusines-mizoramHailakandi, Sep 5 : A delegation of Mizoram Journalists’ Association (MJA) on Friday met the members of the Cachar district unit of Journalists’ Federation of Assam (JFA) at Mizoram Circuit House in Silchar and held discussion regarding the recent conflict over the issue of valid trade licenses to non-Mizo businessmen in Mizoram.

MJA members informed that only 53 non-Mizo businessmen have valid trade license of Mizoram Government and it has come to light after an enquiry conducted in the State by the government. It was informed in the meeting that the Mizoram Government stopped issuing trade licenses to non-Mizos from 1976-77.

The Mizo journalists said that the non-Mizos from Barak Valley go to Mizoram in order to do some business or other jobs and in order to start the business, they marry Mizo girls. It was also informed in the meeting that the non-Mizos are not allowed to do any business without the permission of the government.

The Young Mizo Association (YMA) and some other non-governmental organisations identified the problem of Mizo and non-Mizo marriage and informed the state government urging to frame a strict law in 2010.

MJA delegation informed the meeting that the Mizoram Government has also assured them to take necessary steps in this regard. They said that YMA has started to identify the non-Mizo businessmen those who don’t have valid trade licenses and the Mizoram Government has already cautioned the YMA not take law in their hand, they added.

Both MJA and JFA urged the people concerned to maintain peace and tranquility in Mizoram over the issue of checking valid trade licenses of non-Mizo businessmen. MJA also invited JFA members to visit Mizoram in the second week of September.

For Opposing Bandhs, Assam Outfits ‘Ban’ Singer’s Music

By Samudra Gupta Kashyap 

singer Zubeen Garg assamGuwahati, Sep 5 : Four organisations, claiming to represent a tribal community, on Sunday imposed a ban on the songs, music and videos of Assam’s popular musician and singer Zubeen Garg after the latter lodged an FIR against them for calling a bandh.

Garg, who has also made a name in Hindi cinema by singing Ya Ali a couple of years ago, had last week lodged an FIR at the Morigaon police station against four organisations for calling a 12-hour bandh. He had also sought action against the organisations on the ground that the Gauhati High Court had already declared bandhs as illegal in Assam and Meghalaya.

Garg, along with his wife and costume designer Garima, actor Kapil Bora, and journalist Kaushik Deka had on August 23 lodged a complaint with the CID of Assam Police, naming the presidents of Tiwa Students’ Union, Tiwa Yuva-Chatra Parishad, Tiwa Mahila Sangstha and Tiwa Suraksha Samiti, and questioning why action should not be initiated against them for calling bandhs which were already declared illegal. The groups had called a bandh on August 24.

Though the police are yet to take action on the complaint except for registering a case in the Morigaon police station (the district where the four groups had called the bandh), the four groups have declared a ‘ban’ on songs, music, videos and films featuring Garg and Bora.

The Gauhati High Court had, on the basis of a PIL filed by several eminent citizens and journalists, on January 6, 2010 declared bandhs as illegal in Assam and Meghalaya.

Meanwhile, the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) state unit has called a 9-hour bandh in Assam on Monday to register its protest against the government’s move to swap adversely possessed areas along the boundary with Bangladesh. The state BJP has also extended support to the bandh.

Garg, Bora and others on Sunday filed yet another complaint with the CID against the state units of Vishwa Hindu Parishad and BJP for calling a bandh in Assam on Monday. A case has been registered on the basis of their complaint.

04 September 2011

Trending: The North East

By Hoihnu Hauzel

Think football and what comes to mind is Baichung Bhutia. Instantly and naturally. And what comes to mind when you hear Mary Kom’s name? Boxing, of course. Now, think of where both these sports stars come from. Not many would know that Bhutia and Kom come from two different states in the North East of India.

The North East comprises eight states: Assam, Arunachal Pradesh, Meghalaya, Mizoram, Manipur, Nagaland, Tripura and Sikkim. And often people from this region are mistaken for Chinese! But for those who know them, people from that part of India are a lively bunch who love the good life like everyone else. And if you are GK Pillai, the former Union home secretary, you might like to add that they are “a talented lot.” (Make that “very very talented!”)

North EasternersPillai should know. He has had a long stint as a government official in charge of the region. “There is immense potential in the people and the land. I have been impressed by their talent and creativity. Today, their talents are partly recognised, but they need to be fully recognised,” says Pillai.

To writer and filmmaker Jahnu Barua this recognition of North East talent is just “the beginning of a long journey.” Nonetheless, he says: “The driving force of these people is immense since they know that they have come from so far away to make something out of themselves. So you cannot ignore them anymore.”

Indeed, you can’t. Whether it’s sports, music or fashion, we’re seeing a lot of North Easterners out there. Their food too is preparing to compete with other cuisine in the market. And their unexplored and virgin land is drawing tourists like never before.

So is it time to look East? We think so.

Fashionably yours
FashionThe innately stylish don’t need a big brand to make that statement. Even a simple export surplus off-shoulder top teamed with a label-less made-in-China skirt can give them a diva look. “Brands do not spell style. I am not brand conscious but quality conscious. And we have the ability to understand what looks good on us,” says well-known model from the North East, Esther Jamir. So is being well-dressed part of the North East culture?

Kos Zhasa, former board of governors member of the National Institute of fashion Technology (NIFT), says: “Ours is a very effortless, natural style. I would attribute it to our culture and partly to Western influence because of our faith, Christianity.” Churchgoers in Nagaland often look as though they’re in a fashion show, she says, when they’re dressed in their Sunday best.

Youngsters Winnie Sangtam and Imsu agree that style is a personal thing. “I mix and match and follow my instinct,” says Imsu, a fashion blogger. And Sangtam the student doesn’t dress in the college uniform of salwar kameez or jeans. She stands out in her dress or spaghetti top with jeans.
Naturally, when innate style goes commercial, looks and cuts are bound to be different. Look at designer Atsu Sekhose whose Western sensibility has an impressive client list across India and a niche market overseas. Since he started his own line in 2006, he has never looked back.

Kos Zhasa, a fashion and textile designer from NIFT, started her career as designer for embassy clients. She sold her label, Personal Touch, at up-market stores around the country. Zhasa is now back in Nagaland researching textiles of the North East for book she plans to compile. And as a student at NIFT, Devson Yengkhom, a designer from Manipur, made news when he invented a machine that would produce garments without seams.

Fashion 2Designer Raghavendra Rathore was one of the first designers to experiment with fabrics from the North East. “It was one of the most successful collections that we had ever done and that was purely because of the range of fabrics,” he says. “They had a tremendous recall value and we did exceedingly well where this collection retailed.”

Musically tuned
Give them a guitar and you’ll get a song. While this may be slightly exaggerated, you’ll always find music in North Easterners. Three consecutive winners of the Indian Idol contest were all from the region. Prashant Tamang, Amit Paul (runner up) and Sourabhee Debbarma proved that music is part of their life. And last year, Divine Connection, a gospel band from Nagaland, won the Kurkure Desi Bests Rock show on MTV.

Quietly unnoticed, Abiogenesis, a fusion Naga rock band comprising a husband and wife duo, has been making international waves. In 2008, the band released their album, Rustic Relish, worldwide and made it to the 51st Grammy Awards. Easily the most popular choral group in India is the Shillong Chamber Choir led by Neil Nongkynrih. The choir members sing in foreign languages and Hindi, have won television reality show India’s Got Talent; they also sang for US President Barack Obama on his maiden visit to India.
SourabheeShillong-based music legend Lou Majaw continues to draw crowds from the farthest corners of the world when he celebrates Bob Dylan’s birthday year after year. “I have been singing with the deepest devotion since the 50s,” he says. And every state in the North East boasts multiple musical bands.

But in Nagaland, there is a slightly different approach to music. The state government has set up a Music Task Force that organises India’s biggest rock festival, the Hornbill National Rock Contest, every December. “We see music as an industry and we are focusing on every aspect, including sound, visual media and recording,” says Gugs Sema, director of the Music Task Force.

In Patkai Christian College, a premier college in Dimapur, music is part of the curriculum. And every year, 20 to 30 music graduates pursue higher degrees in music in the state. With over 66 home-grown bands in 11 districts in 2008, the number has only increased over the years. In Shillong, Majaw estimates that Meghalaya has about 15 to 20 local bands who sing in English. Mizoram is not far behind with its own rock band, Magdalene, releasing well-made music videos for local audiences. And Albatross, Frisky Pints and others have performed in metro cities as well.
No wonder then, international stars would rather play in the North East than in India’s big cities. On his maiden trip to India in 2007, Eric Martin, the voice of Mr Big, headed straight to Shillong where other bands like Firehouse and White Lion have played. Pradyot Manikya Deb Burman, the current king of the royal house of Tripura and the man who brings international acts to Shillong, says: “It’s purely for the love of music. There is also a need to show that our region is capable of hosting world class shows. Also, the perception that the region is unsafe had to be removed, and what better way to do it than with packed stadiums?”

Strictly business
If there is a will, there is a way. And when Raja Sithlou and his wife Ahoi returned from a holiday in Thailand in 2006, they were decided. They would start ‘the McDonald’s of spas’. In 2008, the dream came true. The couple now run Oriental Senses at Select Citywalk mall in Delhi, a spa that offers luxurious services at affordable prices. “We saw a great business opportunity in introducing commendable services at affordable rates,” says Raja.

Ahoi trained in Asian massage therapies in Thailand and Indonesia, and now personally trains her staff who are mostly from the interiors of Manipur. “We wanted to do something which will directly help build skills and create employment opportunities for our people,” says Raja. And it helps that most of his staff are from the North East. “A lot of customers do come in thinking that the spa is run by Thais. It does make a difference if the therapist ‘looks’ like a Thai!”

As the head designer for an export house, Dodou Tunglut always wanted to start something of his own. In 2006 he chucked up his job and set up a studio manufacturing home furnishings. Today he caters to high-end boutiques in America and Europe. “People who are familiar with my work keep ordering more,” says Tunglut. As of now, he is researching the textiles of the North East. Mary Claire dived into designing out of sheer passion.

The Mizo, married to an Italian restaurateur, the owner of Delhi’s Flavors, is already making many trips to Europe to meet clients. But for someone who made her own dresses at the age of 12, this is only expected. Claire fuses North East handlooms with frills and adds stones and beads on table runners, mats, and head boards. “They are all sold out in Europe,” she says.

Lost and found
RhinoA few years ago, heading to the North East for a holiday would have been unthinkable. Forget the insurgency problems. There weren’t enough hotels! It was also difficult to get there. Now, there are more direct flights to the region than ever before. And accommodation? You are spoilt for choice. So tourist traffic to the North East has really taken off. Assam, for instance, had 36.7 lakh domestic arrivals in Assam in 2008. In 2010, it was 40.51 lakh.
“The region is clearly poised for a growth in economic activity, linked both to the huge tourism potential and the availability of resources, natural and human. Hence, we anticipate that the region will see a greater presence of branded hotels, going forward,” says Prabhat Pani, CEO & director, Roots Corporation Limited.

Locals are also doing their bit. Take for instance Pradyot Manikya Deb Burman, the current king of the royal house of Tripura, who opened a heritage resort by converting his family’s summer home into a hotel, Tripura Castle, in Shillong. He is now adding a few more rooms, another restaurant and a spa.

“The market is growing. There is a definite demand for high-end hotels in places like Kaziranga,” says Subrto Sharma who invested in a luxury resort in a tea garden in Kaziranga. Says Rakesh Mathur, president of Welcomheritage which has a slew of properties in Jorhat, Sikkim, Arunachal and elsewhere, “It was only a question of time for us to promote the North East as a destination. The doors have opened and the time is ripe.”

Mayfair Hotels & Resorts has opened the region’s first luxury resort in Gangtok, complete with spa, helipad and casino. And ITDC, which owns two hotels in the region, is open to proposals for new hotels.

New star on the Culinary map
North east kitchenWhen 12-Michelin star chef Gordon Ramsay came to India to shoot a Great Escape episode, he headed to Nagaland and Assam. Two recipes, fish tenga, a sour fish curry from Assam, and Majuli fish cakes with tomato, another local dish, made it to his 100 favourite recipes from India. And when Italian slow food icon Carlos Pertini came to India, it was in Meghalaya that he bonded with locals over sumptuous pork curry and herbs and spices that he was surprised to see. “I have never had such delicious food,” said Pertini.

There is something about the flavour from this region. Considered exotic anyway by gourmet gurus, the simple but healthy and flavourful food that uses natural spices and little oil is slowly finding takers. Celebrated chef Bill Marchetti for one, thinks the cuisine has huge potential.

So it’s no surprise to see Nagaland’s Kitchen, a 48-cover fine dining eatery right in the middle of Green Park Extension market in Delhi, vying for attention and customers with more established neighbourhood restaurants. Chubamanen Longkumar, all of 29, and his two sisters, owners of the restaurant, are more than confident that this venture will work. Why not? The siblings from Nagaland have already felt the pulse of locals with more than a decade of successfully running the buzzing Nagaland Kitchen at Delhi’s arts and crafts junction, Dilli Haat. They know that soon, their sumptuous smoked pork curry, Naga thali and other authentic dishes will find more converts. Since they first opened last October, their restaurant has attracted 60-70 diners a day.

So it’s not surprising that even five-star kitchens are intrigued by North Eastern cuisine. Take the Park in Delhi. It has incorporated a dish from Manipur in its coffee shop menu after a North East food promotion was held in the hotel. At the Oberoi in Gurgaon, executive chef Ravitej promises that their multicuisine restaurant threesixtyone will soon feature a smattering of North Eastern dishes too.

Ravitej was prompted to do this when one of his chefs, Siamsang from Manipur, asked him to sample a Manipuri dish. “It was tasty and different and I felt I could take it up to a commercial level,” he says. It will need initiation, though, he adds. Just like the Japanese and non-Schezwan Chinese food that were introduced in small doses. “We will use the same approach to promote North Eastern food,” he says.

And chef Praveen Anand of Chennai’s ITC Sheraton will soon hold a long-planned Brahmin Manipuri food festival in his restaurant. “It will be during navratra as I intend to serve only vegetarian dishes that are best prepared by the Manipuri Brahmins,” he says. “There are a number of connoisseurs in Chennai who would love to eat something new. In my research I realised that there is so much to unearth from the North East.”

Chef Sabyasachi Gorai of the Japanese restaurant, Ai in Delhi, knows this. He has been quietly sourcing his ingredients from there for half the price he would have paid in Japan. Organic blackberries, passionfruit, black mushrooms, flat bamboo leaves, black rice and more come from Shillong. Gorai vouches for the quality and freshness. “The North East is home to many interesting ingredients,” says Gorai.

Good sports
BhaichungCircumstances have made them fighters and winners in their chosen fields. Whether it is Mary Kom, three-time world champion, or gold medallist boxer Dhinko Singh or weightlifter Kunjarani Devi or soccer king Baichung Bhutia, they all say hard work was their mantra. “Whether it’s training, cooking or housework, Kom does everything with precision and perfection,” says Kom’s husband Onler.

Soccer star Baichung Bhutia, the first Indian to play for a European team, believes the highest number of footballers in India come from the North East. “Football is bigger than cricket here,” he says. “Also, kids are much more energetic here and the weather is generally good for outdoor games.” To catch that talent, Bhutia’s newly-formed club, United Sikkim, will be perfect. “This is going to be the biggest and most professionally-run club in the country,” he says. “I see a lot of young talent all over India and this can be a platform for them.”

Literally speaking
And now, it seems the “most interesting voice in India” is from the North East. And VK Karthika, chief editor of HarperCollins India, is serious when she says that. Karthika is referring to Kynpham Sing Nongkynrih whose poetry has just been published by HarperCollins India. “He has a sophistication of thought and ideas which is combined with a very dramatic story-telling voice,” says Karthika. “We have not explored voices from the North East before.”

For a long time, writing from the North East remained confined to the region. Sometimes, it was because good writers did not necessarily write in English. Kynpham, 46, for instance, says that he has been writing in Khasi and English for more than two decades. But as translations take off, you’ll read more from the region. Zubaan, for instance, has translations from Assamese in their list.

For more than a decade, a group of writers under the North East Writers’ Forum has been meeting and encouraging its members to write. “And they are committed writers who write for the love of it and not necessarily to be published or with any political agenda,” says Karthika. “We have been getting good manuscripts.”

Preeti Gill, editor of Zubaan, says writing from the North East has a certain freshness and strength that compels the reader. “And to me, it presents a reality that many of us were unaware of till recently,” she says. “I see a certain truth, honesty, a brutal ‘reportage’, retelling of popular myths, of local histories, of community stories. It’s a very exciting area with rich literary traditions and there is much to be discovered.”

Zubaan has in fact held writers’ forums where writers from the North East have interacted with fellow writers from other states. Gill has personally built up Zubaan’s list of titles by travelling in the region and getting in touch with new writers through friends and associates.

Source: Hindustan Times

Cancer On The Rise in Northeast India

By Sobhapati Samom
 

Tobacco Northeast India_thumbImphal, Sep 4 : Cancer cases are on the rise in the conflict- ridden regions such as North Eastern States and Jammu & Kashmir.

Speaking to media persons on the eve of a two-day cancer awareness program and cancer screening camp here, Dr Sameer Kaul, renowned Surgical Oncologist of the country today said, “Looking at our experiences cancer seems to be predominant disease in the conflict zones. Stress factors could be a reason. But so far no study has been done in this regard”.

Informing that the new trend was reported in the conflict zones such as Afghanistan, Iran, Sri Lanka, besides Jammu & Kashmir and NE States in India, President of Breast Cancer Patients Benefit Foundation (BCPBF) Dr Sameer, however, opined the need to have a retrospective study in this connection.

Dr Sameer is leading a team of noted oncologists in the country to conduct a two-day free cancer screening camp from Sunday at Shija Hospital here besides organizing awareness programs. More than 200 persons have registered for the camp till Saturday afternoon.

According to BCPBF head, though there are more cervical cancer cases than the breast cancers in rural India, the latter outnumbered the common (cancer) cases in the urban areas.

Surgical Oncologist of Apollo Hospital, Dr Feroz Pasha said, “We are shocked to see cancer cases of the State were brought for treatment at the last stage. That is why we came here to detect it at the earliest”.

Dr Deepali Kapoor, Counseling Psychologist, also from Apollo Hospital said awareness is the need of the hour while Dr Kh Palin of Shija Hospital feels that lack of awareness and unavailability of advanced treatment are the main lacunae in cancer treatment in Manipur.

With 1,269 new cases including 643 women, Manipur has the highest number of lung cancer cases in India in 2008 as per annual reports of the population based cancer registries of the State. “The status remains the same till date”, confirmed Dr Y Mohen who heads the State unit of the cancer registry when contacted.